Best litter boxes for odor control. Litter on the floor, smell in the hall? Go top-entry.
A top-entry box keeps both inside and its textured lid takes litter off paws. Can't jump? A high-sided open box. Likes a hood? One with a built-in filter.
A top-entry box keeps both inside and its textured lid takes litter off paws.
Closest to a mess free litter box: the IRIS USA Large Top Entry Cat Litter Box, if your cat can jump; the lid keeps smell and scatter inside.
Old or stiff cat: a high-sided open box with a low front.
A lid only holds smell; the scoop is what removes it.
In this guide14 sections
Barefoot at 6 a.m., a crunch of litter, a smell waiting in the hall. Pick the box by how your cat moves, then keep it on a routine. Four steps.
Cat jumps easily? Get a top-entry box like the IRIS USA Large Top Entry (see IRIS USA at Amazon).
Cat old, stiff or wary of lids? Get a high-sided open box with a low front instead.
Fill it with unscented clumping litter, deep enough for your cat to dig and bury.
Start the scoop routine further down the page today, whichever box you chose.
Top-entry boxes hold smell and scatter in
An open box loses on both counts: kicked litter lands on your floor, the crunch underfoot, and the smell drifts out into the room. A top-entry box closes the gap from above. The lid keeps the smell inside, and its textured surface catches litter from paws as your cat climbs out. Cat can't jump? Go to the open box section: high sides, low front.
Not sure whether the smell starts in the box, the litter or the bin? Take the litter box smell quiz.
Do you need a filter with the pick? No. A filter only helps a little between scoops and never takes waste out.
The picks side by side
Pick
Best for
The catch
Our pickIRIS USA Large Top Entry
Best forKeeping smell in and litter off the floor
The catchTop entry suits cats that jump. Stiff or tiny? Pick a low-entry box.
Also greatNature's Miracle Hooded Flip Top
Best forCats that will use a hood
The catchSome cats won't walk into a dark hood
What makes a litter box mess free?
Cats bury like they're hiding evidence, so the walls do real work. A high-sided open box catches the kick but holds no smell, so it needs the scoop even more.
Which box type smells least
Enclosed boxes hold smell in best, and open boxes are easiest for every cat to use. Pick the most enclosed box your cat will actually walk into. Smell still the problem? Compare Dr. Elsey's vs Coir Wonder vs Litter Genie for litter smell.
Open, low sides: easy in and out, holds no smell, kicks litter everywhere. Good for kittens and stiff seniors.
Open, high sides: keeps scatter and spray in, still easy to enter. The best open option.
Covered (hooded): holds smell in, but some cats won't go into a dark box.
Top-entry: holds smell and scatter in, and paws drop litter on the lid on the way out. Needs a cat that can jump.
Automatic: clears waste soon after each visit, but some cats run from the motor noise.
More enclosed means less smell, but only if your cat will walk in.
Do carbon filters and vented lids help?
A little, between scoops. A charcoal filter pad inside a hooded box traps some of the smell that builds under the lid; PurifyLogix pads are swapped about once a month. No filter or vent takes waste out, so the scoop still does the real work. Want the filter built in? The hooded pick below has one.
Will your cat use a covered box?
Probably. A small study in the Journal of Feline Medicine and Surgery (Grigg, Pick and Nibblett, published online 2012) gave 28 cats a covered box and an open box, both scooped daily. As a group the cats showed no preference: four chose covered, four chose open, and the rest used both.
The study's authors suspect that if boxes are cleaned at least once a day, most cats will not show a preference for either type, and they suggest offering a mix of box styles, a covered one included. The ASPCA leans the other way and says most cats don't like lids on their boxes, so treat the lid as something your cat votes on, not a rule.
If your cat starts going next to the box, offer one of each side by side and let it vote. Still going outside the box? See why a cat pees outside the litter box.
Our pick: IRIS USA Large Top Entry box
The IRIS USA Large Top Entry is the box to buy if litter tracking and smell are both the problem. Your cat climbs in through the lid, so scatter stays inside the box.
The lid is textured, so litter falls off paws on the way out instead of landing on your floor. The catch: every trip starts with a jump onto the lid. Skip it if your cat is a senior or stiff in the hips. A high-sided open box with a low front is the one to buy (see Best open box, below). Kitten? Start in a low open box.
Pick the Nature's Miracle Hooded Flip Top for a cat that walks into a hood but won't jump onto a lid. The hood keeps the smell under cover, and the charcoal filter comes built in, so there are no separate pads to buy for it.
The catch
A front door lets kicked litter out where a top-entry lid would hold it, and a cat that dislikes dark spaces may refuse the hood. Set it beside an open box for the first days and watch which one gets used.
Best open box: high sides, low entry
Choose a high-sided open box for a cat that refuses lids or can't jump. The tall back and sides catch spray and kicked litter, and a low front lets an older cat step in.
The trade-off is smell. Nothing holds odor in, so scoop it every day without fail. Skip a day and your nose files the complaint.
Is an automatic box worth it?
Only if your cat tolerates the noise and you'd rather not scoop every day. It removes waste soon after each visit, which is the best smell control there is.
It still needs litter refills and regular cleaning, motors break, and some cats won't go near it. A top-entry box you scoop comes close for far less fuss.
Going automatic? The liners are a running cost too. PETOCAT drawstring liners are made for the LR3, LR4 and compatible self-cleaning boxes. Measure yours first: they fit up to 12.5 x 11.8 x 7 in.
Match the box to your home
See the 5 pointsHide this section
One cat, smell and scatter: a top-entry box plus unscented clumping litter.
Several cats: one box per cat plus one extra, at least one of them open.
Senior cat: a high-sided open box with a low entry.
Kitten: a low open box now, a bigger box later.
Cat fine with a hood, can't jump: a hooded box with a built-in filter.
The ASPCA gives the same count for several cats: a box for each cat, plus one extra. It also says most cats prefer large boxes they can enter easily, set in a quiet spot that is not cornered and is away from busy, loud or intimidating places.
Switching boxes without a litter strike
Set the new box next to the old one and fill it with the litter your cat already uses. Leave both out until the new box gets regular visits, then take the old one away.
Change one thing at a time. A new box and a new litter in the same week leaves your cat with two surprises and you with no idea which one it objects to. If you do switch litter later, compare clumping and non-clumping litter first.
A cat that sniffs the top-entry lid and walks off is not refusing for good. Give it time beside the familiar box instead of removing the old one early, which is what pushes a cat to the carpet.
Keep any box from smelling
Scooping beats any box design. Do these and most boxes stop smelling:
Scoop twice a day, morning and evening.
Keep about 2 inches of clumping litter so clumps form and lift out whole.
Empty and wash the box with soap and water every week, then dry it fully.
Replace a plastic box once it's scratched and still smells after washing. Scratches hold odor.
Scooping takes the smell out; a lid only holds it in.
For the baseline, the ASPCA says to scoop at least once a day and, once a week, clean every box with warm water and unscented soap. It adds that most cats prefer clumping, unscented litter. Twice a day, as above, is our higher bar for a covered box.
Unscented clumping litter such as Dr. Elsey's Precious Cat Ultra makes the scoop quick, and nothing masks a box that needs it. Box sorted? Our cat litter and odor control picks and cat air quality picks cover the rest of the smell fight.
A better box with the same smell usually means the cause sits somewhere else. Work down this list before you buy anything more.
A scoop got skipped: under a lid, one missed evening means a night of waste sealed in with your cat, and the smell greets you when you lift it.
The litter runs thin: urine reaches the plastic floor and soaks into scratches there. Top it up to the depth in the routine above.
The litter is scented: perfume sits on top of the smell rather than removing it, and some cats avoid a strongly scented box.
The box sits in a shut closet: still air holds the smell in the room. Move it to a quiet spot where air moves, your cat can reach it easily, and its food and water are elsewhere.
The smell is in the floor: if your cat has gone beside the box, the urine is in the rug or subfloor, not the box. Here is why pet odor keeps coming back and how to get it out.
Moving her water bowl away from the box? A fountain set up in its own quiet spot is an easy upgrade: see our cat water fountains.
If your cat suddenly changes how or where it goes, ask your vet. A change in litter box habits can have a health cause that no box will fix.
The AAFP and ISFM feline environmental needs guidelines call a cat's environmental needs essential, not optional, which is why a cat that suddenly avoids its box deserves a vet visit and a look at the setup before you blame the box.
Considered, didn't make it
See the 2 pointsHide this section
An automatic box: left off the picks because it only suits a cat calm around a motor, and it adds a part that can fail. The full trade-off is in the automatic box section above.
A low open box: right for a kitten's first weeks or a cat that struggles with any step, but it does nothing for smell or scatter, which is the job of this page.
Verdict: top-entry if your cat jumps, open if it can't
Choose by how your cat moves, then let the routine carry the rest. A jumper gets the IRIS USA Large Top Entry, which catches the crunch on the way out. A cat that can't climb gets a high-sided open box with a low front, and a cat happy under a hood gets the Nature's Miracle Hooded Flip Top. Whichever you buy, the scoop does the work no lid can. Not sure which litter? See how to choose cat litter.
Buying for a cat lover? Start with the litter box chore in our gifts for cat lovers guide.
Sources we checked
ASPCA, Litter Box Problems: a box per cat plus one, large boxes, quiet location, daily scooping, weekly wash with unscented soap, clumping unscented litter, most cats dislike lids.
A top-entry box like the IRIS USA Large Top Entry holds smell and kicked litter in best. It needs a cat that can jump onto the lid.
How often should you scoop a litter box to stop the smell?
Twice a day, morning and evening. Keep about 2 inches of clumping litter so clumps lift out whole.
When should you replace a plastic litter box?
Once it's scratched and still smells after washing. Scratches hold odor.
Do covered litter boxes smell less?
Less smell reaches the room, because the hood keeps it inside. The waste is still there until you scoop, and your cat is the one standing in it, so a covered box needs the same routine as an open one.
Can a litter box go in a closet?
Only with the door propped open and some air moving. A shut closet traps the smell and can lock your cat out. A quiet corner with airflow, away from food and water, works better.