Clumping wins for most cats, because the pee lifts out with every scoop.
Start with Dr. Elsey's Precious Cat Ultra Unscented.
Kitten or litter eater? Ask your vet about non-clumping.
In this guide9 sections
You tip the box into the bin, and the pee smell climbs out. Clumping litter lets you lift the pee out with every scoop; non-clumping keeps it in the tray until you dump the lot.
Pour it deep enough that pee clumps before it reaches the floor of the tray.
Scoop the clumps and the poop every day, then top up with fresh litter.
Empty the box, wash it and refill it once a week.
Ask your vet first if you have a kitten or a cat who eats litter.
Box still smells with clumping litter? Check these five things
Clumps fall apart in the scoop. The litter is too shallow, so pee reaches the tray floor and smears. Add more litter until clumps lift out whole.
You scoop every other day. Scoop daily. Clumping only works when the clump leaves the box.
It has been weeks since a full change. Topping up never removes the crumbs of pee you missed. Empty, wash and refill once a week.
The box itself smells. An old, scratched plastic box can hold smell. Wash it with unscented dish soap and water, and replace it if the smell stays.
A scented litter is covering for it. Perfume on top of pee is still pee. An unscented litter tells you when it's time to scoop.
The picks side by side
Pick
Best for
The catch
Our pickDr. Elsey's Precious Cat Ultra
Best forCats that avoid scented litter
The catchHeavy 40 lb bag. Pour low to keep dust down.
Also greatWorld's Best Cat Litter Comfort
Best forA plant-based litter
The catchSome cats dislike the corn smell.
Clumping wins for most cats
Is clumping or non-clumping litter better? Clumping, for most cats. Wet litter binds into a solid clump you lift out, so the pee smell leaves the box every time you scoop instead of soaking in for the week.
The catch
It only pays off if you scoop daily. A clump left sitting in the box smells like any other pee.
The exceptions are real, though: a kitten, a cat who eats litter, or a cat who simply refuses clumping. More on those below.
The litter binds wherever it gets wet, gluing itself into a lump around the pee. You scoop the clumps and the poop, then top up with fresh litter. The box stays mostly clean litter between full changes.
The catch
Clay clumping litter can be dusty when you pour it, and the bags are heavy.
Non-clumping
It soaks up pee like a sponge, but nothing forms to scoop. You lift out poop, and the pee stays in the litter until you empty the whole box and start over. Do that often, or the smell builds up fast.
Where it wins: it's often lighter, and some cats like the texture.
Side by side: what changes in your week
See the 5 pointsHide this section
The daily job. Clumping: scoop the clumps and the poop, then top up. Non-clumping: scoop the poop and leave the pee where it soaked in.
The full change. Clumping: empty and wash the box once a week. Non-clumping: much more often, because every day adds more pee to the same litter.
The smell. Clumping takes the pee out with each scoop. Non-clumping holds it, so the box smells stronger the longer you wait to dump it.
Weight and dust. Clay clumping bags are heavy and can puff dust when you pour. Non-clumping is often lighter to carry.
Who it suits. Clumping suits most adult cats. Non-clumping suits kittens and litter eaters, with your vet's say-so.
When non-clumping litter is the right call: kittens and litter eaters
Kittens. Young kittens sometimes taste their litter. Ask your vet which type to use and when to switch.
A cat who eats litter. Call your vet first, since eating litter can point to a health or behavior problem, and ask whether non-clumping is the safer pick.
Your vet recommends it for a specific reason.
Your cat won't use anything else. A box your cat uses beats a box with better litter that your cat avoids.
Going non-clumping? Plan on dump days: tip the whole box, then wash the tray each time. Topping up soaked litter only puts fresh litter on top of old pee.
Your cat hates perfume: Dr. Elsey's Precious Cat Ultra
Unscented clumping clay that forms hard clumps. Natural clay is the only ingredient on the maker's page, with no perfumes or deodorants. Nothing hides a box that needs scooping, which is a feature. Comes in a 40 lb bag.
Best for: A cat who walks away from scented litter, and an owner who wants a box that tells the truth about when it needs scooping.
The catch: Some dust when you pour, and 40 lb is a workout.
Skip it if: Hauling 40 lb is the dealbreaker. World's Best comes in a lighter 32 lb bag.
Clumping litter made from corn instead of clay, with no added scent, in a 32 lb bag. The maker says the corn is grown in the U.S. You scoop it the same way.
Best for: An owner who wants clumping without clay, in a bag lighter than the 40 lb Dr. Elsey's.
The catch: Some cats dislike the corn smell. Keep the bag sealed and dry.
Skip it if: Box smell is the main complaint. Arm & Hammer Clump & Seal mixes in baking soda.
Switching litters without a protest
Mix a little of the new litter into the old.
Shift the mix toward the new one a little at a time.
If your cat starts going outside the box, slow down or go back. And if it keeps happening, call your vet.
Our verdict: clumping, unless your vet says otherwise
Buy clumping litter for an adult cat, and start with Dr. Elsey's Precious Cat Ultra: unscented, natural clay, hard clumps. Then the weekly tip into the bin is a fresh start, not a rescue. Go non-clumping for a kitten (with your vet's say-so), a litter eater or a cat who votes with their paws.
Whichever bag you buy, the daily scoop does more for the smell than the litter does. Skip it for two days and any box smells like a box.
Check the bag. Clay litter isn't made to be flushed, and your plumbing won't love it either. When in doubt, bag it and bin it.
How often should I change it all out?
Clumping: scoop daily and top up, then empty and wash the box every week. Non-clumping: much more often, since the pee stays in.
Does clumping litter control smell better than non-clumping?
It removes more of it. The pee leaves the box with each clump you scoop. Non-clumping holds the pee until you empty the whole box, so the smell builds between changes.
Can I mix clumping and non-clumping litter?
Yes, while you switch from one to the other. Long term, pick one: the non-clumping part of a mix holds pee that the scoop can't lift out.
Is clumping litter okay for kittens?
Ask your vet. Young kittens sometimes taste their litter, so the vet can tell you which type to use and when to move to clumping.
Is corn litter clumping?
Some is. World's Best Cat Litter Comfort Care is a clumping corn litter: you scoop it the same way as clay, and it has no clay in it.