The catch: Old stain? Soak it at bedtime and let it work overnight.
The maker states: Enzyme formulaThe maker states: it uses enzymes, which break down the pee or vomit itself, so the smell goes with it.
The maker states: Made in USAThe maker states: it is made in the USA, with no qualifier. Under FTC rules, that claim has to mean all or virtually all of it is made here.
Fresh puddle: Naturally It's Clean. Old stain: Rocco & Roxie.
You found it. How old is it? Fresh: blot, spray, let it sit, blot again with Naturally It's Clean. Dried weeks ago: Rocco & Roxie, the overnight soak.
Which one to get: pick by the age of the stain
Get Naturally It's Clean if the pee is fresh and on carpet, or you want a cleaner that advertises plant-based enzymes and no dyes or artificial fragrances. Blot, spray, let it sit, blot again. The catch: it is built for fresh carpet spots, so for a set-in stain switch to Rocco & Roxie.
Get Rocco & Roxie if the pee is dried, keeps coming back to the same spot, or sits on tile, wood or concrete. Soak it, leave it overnight, let it air dry. The catch: you need patience, and it is made for pee, poop and vomit. Ink or dye? Reach for a spot remover.
Find your stain, find your bottle
Stain age: fresh and damp points to Naturally It's Clean. Dried or repeat spots point to Rocco & Roxie.
Surface: Naturally It's Clean is made for carpets. Rocco & Roxie is made for carpet plus tile, wood and concrete.
Wait time: Rocco & Roxie wants longer on a fresh spot: its product page says let it stand 30 to 60 minutes, then blot. On old pee, overnight. Naturally It's Clean is the spray-and-blot bottle for a fresh puddle.
Scent: Naturally It's Clean says no artificial fragrances. Rocco & Roxie lists fragrance among its ingredients on its product page.
What else it covers: Naturally It's Clean breaks down food, wine, coffee and pet stains. Rocco & Roxie is made for pee, poop and vomit.
Steam cleaner: Rocco & Roxie says not to run it through one, because the high heat can deactivate its biological ingredients.
Fresh pee on carpet: Naturally It's Clean wins
Fresh and damp is the spray-and-blot job. Blot, spray, let it sit, blot again. Naturally It's Clean advertises no dyes or artificial fragrances, and it is made for carpets.
Winner: Naturally It's Clean, for a fresh spot on carpet.
Old, dried or repeat spots: Rocco & Roxie wins
The directions are about time, not scrubbing. Pour it on until it reaches as deep as the pee did, leave it overnight, then let it air dry. On carpet, soak past the visible edge, because pee spreads wider underneath than it looks on top.
Rocco & Roxie says it is chlorine-free and color-safe. Spot-test a hidden corner of the rug first anyway.
Winner: Rocco & Roxie, because the overnight soak is the whole design.
Tile, wood and concrete: Rocco & Roxie wins
Rocco & Roxie is made for tile, wood and concrete. Pour it on and leave it. On wood, let the first round dry fully before you add more, so the boards dry between rounds.
Naturally It's Clean's page covers carpets, so keep it for the rug.
Winner: Rocco & Roxie.
Fragrance: Naturally It's Clean wins
Want to skip artificial scent? Naturally It's Clean advertises no dyes or artificial fragrances. Rocco & Roxie lists fragrance among its ingredients.
Winner: Naturally It's Clean, on scent.
Neither if
The smell is still there after two full rounds with dry time between them. The pee has probably reached the pad or the subfloor. Read the deep fix for pad and subfloor.
The stain is ink or dye. Both bottles are made for organic messes, so reach for a spot remover.
Pick one per round. Start with Naturally It's Clean on a fresh spot. If the smell is still there after two full rounds with dry time between them, switch to Rocco & Roxie: soak it, leave it overnight, let it air dry.
Does Rocco & Roxie work on carpet?
Yes, it is made for carpet and for tile, wood and concrete. Soak the spot as deep as the pee went, leave it overnight, and let it air dry.
Which one for an old stain?
Rocco & Roxie. Its directions are built around long soaks, with overnight for older spots.
